In October, anthropology professor Matt Samson drafted a letter to Davidson College President Doug Hicks ‘90 protesting the recent announcement that Senator Thom Tillis would serve as “leader-in-residence” next year at the Martin Institute for Public Good. Samson condemned Tillis as “antithetical” to Davidson’s values, and 41 other faculty members apparently agreed, co-signing the letter.
According to Samson, Tillis doesn’t represent the values that he thinks the college should represent. Even one of the most moderate Republicans in the Senate is apparently too far. Tillis’ Heritage Action score for the 119th Congress, which measures alignment with conservative policies, is only 65%. Tillis has even recently made a high-profile break with the president, as one of only three republican senators to vote against the “Big Beautiful Bill,” a core part of President Trump’s legislative agenda.
What could Tillis’ offenses possibly be? According to the Davidsonian, Tillis has “voted to block Medicaid expansion and public higher education funding in North Carolina, voted for bills to fund immigration enforcement and has opposed same-sex marriage.”
What do Davidson’s values have to do with expanding Medicaid, not funding immigration enforcement, or trying to change the definition of marriage? Nothing in Davidson’s Statement of Purpose contains any such policy prescriptions. Implying that Davidson’s values necessitate holding particular policy positions unfairly ends debate before it can even begin. How do we know that the best way to uphold human dignity is to increase funding for the Medicaid bureaucracy, already costing American taxpayers nearly $1 trillion per year? What about human dignity necessitates abandoning the definition of marriage, upheld by virtually every society in the history of the world until, at the earliest, 2001? We should all recognize that good people, holding many of the same basic values, can reasonably come down on different sides of these issues. We should not equate personal applications of Davidson’s values with those values themselves.
Last month, I was excited to learn that a conservative voice such as Tillis would be involved with Davidson. But I was startled and saddened to learn that so many professors felt the need to publicly dissent over someone with moderately conservative views becoming a leader-in-residence.
It is even more startling to consider the chilling effect that this public dissent against conservatism may have on free speech across campus. When students see dozens of their professors condemning the appointment of an experienced public servant over his moderately conservative views, we cannot expect an open and healthy discourse.
Hostility to conservatives on campus is not new. From Yik Yak posts mocking the assassination of Charlie Kirk to calls for a Davidson student’s expulsion over her terse response to hecklers, the Davidson community’s commitment to free speech has been increasingly infected with intolerance. Last month, Aidan Marks ‘27 called for Rep. Greg Murphy (R-NC-3), who is the only practicing surgeon in Congress, to be disinvited from a talk about medical ethics. In the hours after Murphy spoke, Davidson College Democrats distributed pamphlets condemning the college’s decision to invite Murphy.
What did Murphy do? Six years ago, he pointed out what then-candidate Joe Biden himself had admitted: that vice presidential candidate Kamala Harris had been picked from a shortlist already exclusively composed of women, and intentionally skewed towards Black women. Murphy tweeted, “@KamalaHarris…was only picked for her color and her race…is that how we pick our leaders now in America??” Congressman Murphy could not be “sexist” for pointing out what Joe Biden had explicitly promised in the March 15, 2020, Democratic primary debate. While it is possible to misread Murphy’s tweet as denying that Harris had any qualifications besides being a Black woman, this interpretation is unfair. Among dozens of qualified candidates of every race and gender, limiting the selection by race and gender certainly gives the impression that those are the ultimate qualifications.
In a supposedly worse offense, Murphy invoked 9/11 to criticize Congresswoman Ilhan Omar. In the aftermath of a Capitol Police officer’s murder in April 2021, Omar tweeted, “The death toll would have been worse if the assailant had an AR-15 instead of a knife.” Murphy responded, “Would have been worse @Ilhan if they had been flying planes into the buildings also.” In March 2019, Congresswoman Omar had trivialized the murder of almost 3,000 people on 9/11 as “some people did something” while defending the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR), which critics allege has direct ties to the Palestinian terrorist group Hamas. While CAIR has denied any connection, the FBI severed ties with the group in 2009 following the Holy Land Foundation terrorism financing trial, in which CAIR was named as an unindicted co-conspirator. There is nothing “Islamophobic” about pointing out the carnage of radical Islamic terrorism to a congresswoman who has consistently downplayed it.
Neither Marks’s personal interpretation of the Statement of Purpose nor Professor Samson’s personal values should take precedence over Davidson’s commitment to freedom of expression. While free speech can never be absolute, and every community must maintain certain boundaries, it can never be unacceptable to point out the truth or to hold conservative values. If either Murphy’s or Tillis’ presence is unacceptable, how can we defend our identity as a campus open to diverse viewpoints? Luckily, neither has been disinvited. But far too many Davidson students and faculty unfortunately share these intolerant attitudes.
I applaud President Hicks for defending his decision to invite Senator Tillis. While their speech is protected, the faculty who signed the letter should retract it and acknowledge that a healthy environment of free speech means that we often have to accommodate views with which we disagree. Aidan Marks was wrong to condemn Murphy and call for his disinvitation. We should welcome Senator Tillis and Congressman Murphy as much-needed diverse voices in a campus environment that has grown increasingly insulated and intolerant.
Davidson thrives when we uphold our commitment to freedom of expression. We cannot abandon it.



